Guggenheim Museum imposed on Taj Mahal, forced mix of tradition and modern

 







ARCHITECTURE INTRODUCTION Modern Tradition

Preserving Culture in Architecture

"I never design a building before I've seen the site and met the people who will be using it."
--Frank Lloyd Wright

....Like many other things, I like extremes. With my enjoyment of cutting edge modern structures, I truly love traditional/old structures. Traditional structures have so much history written in them, they represent aesthetics of the time before our time. Besides just history, they do posses beauty. While modern may transcend geographic and cultural boundaries, traditional does not. This capacity of preserving culture in traditional architecture makes me appreciate it more. Without the truly traditional structures of Jeddah remaining (which the government has made efforts to preserve), Jeddah would not be and cannot be identified as something Saudi or Arab. Looking at some of the newer areas of Jeddah, one can hardly identify what makes Jeddah a Saudi city.

MODERN/TRADITIONAL SYNTHESIS

Does an attempt at preserving the traditional architecture mean that modern forms have to be stopped or restricted? It certainly does not. What I think should happen is that architecture of a place should reflect the place's cultural and historical make-up. In a place like Saudi Arabia, a quite modern and developed[ing] nation, modern architecture is normal and acceptable, but the nations deep rooted Islamic tradition and history cannot be ignored. In situations like these, compromise should be made. I think that is precisely what is being done in many areas of Saudi Arabia. Modern designs are borrowing from the traditional geometric designs common to the Islamic world. A good example is the Riyadh airport (see below). An even better example is the area around the Prophet's mosque in Madinah. Huge Manhattan size block of buildings (apartments and hotels mostly) are being built with the wooden window structures that are distinct to western Saudi Arabia.

Click for larger images

return to frontpage
previous category